Skip to content
Platform

Find & understand

Discover companiesFrom the market to your shortlistStock ScreenerSee a shortlist take shapeCompany researchUnderstand the business behind a stock

Test & prepare

Reality CheckPut an investing rule in perspectivePlan your riskWork out what is at stake

Keep developing

Review & learnReflect on decisions and build knowledgeAll workspace toolsFind your next starting point
Reality CheckAcademyPricing
Sign inGet started free
All questions

Does buying SPY when RSI(2) is below 10 beat buy and hold?

estockes · Answer · Educational, not advice · Computed 2026-11-14

No: from Nov 13, 2006 to Nov 13, 2026, the rule “buy when RSI(2) is under 10, sell after 2 days” returned +211.2% on SPY after costs, while simply holding SPY returned +680.5%. It made 289 trades and was invested 11% of the time, with a worst drop of -19.8% against -55.2% for holding. Costs were modelled at 2 bp of slippage per side and no commission, and cash earned the 3-month Treasury bill rate while the rule was out of the market.

See all 19 tested rules in one table

Buy when RSI(2) is under 10, sell after 2 days, SPY, Nov 13, 2006 to Nov 13, 2026. Starting with $100,000; 2 bp of slippage per side and no commission on the rule.
The ruleHolding SPY
Total return after costs+211.2%+680.5%
Return per year+5.8%+10.8%
Worst drop from a high-19.8%-55.2%
Time invested11%100%
Trades2891 (buy once)
Sharpe ratio over T-bills0.470.54

Run the same rule on the latest 5 years of daily prices. The result opens right away.

Run this rule on the last 5 years, free

Free, no account needed. A historical simulation with modelled costs, not a forecast.

Before you rely on it

  • Data: 5,032 daily sessions of SPY from Twelve Data, Nov 13, 2006 to Nov 13, 2026, adjusted for splits and dividends. Computed Nov 14, 2026 with the estockes Reality Check engine.
  • The rule is read on each day's close and trades at the next day's open, long only, with the whole account. Holding is a buy on the first day with no costs.
  • At 10 bp of slippage per side, the rule returned +96.0%; before any costs it returned +249.2%.
  • This is a historical simulation. It describes the past, does not predict the future, and is not advice.

Related questions

Why compare a rule with simply holding?

Holding SPY needs no decisions and no trades. A rule is only worth its effort and risk if it ends with more than that, after costs, over the same days.

Did the rule at least lose less in bad markets?

Yes. Its worst drop from a high was -19.8%, against -55.2% for holding SPY, mostly because it was in cash 89% of the time.

Did it work in the last two years?

From Nov 13, 2024 to Nov 13, 2026 the rule returned +38.8% after costs on 34 trades. Over the whole test, 5 of 5 equal four-year periods made money.

Can I run this test myself?

Yes. The link on this page opens the same rule in the free Reality Check, which tests the last 5 years without an account. Testing 20 years needs Pro.

Keep going

  • All tested questions
  • Rules we tested with held-back data
  • Lesson: RSI and oscillators
  • Test your own rule

Change the ticker and run the same rule on a stock you follow.

Run the same rule on your own ticker

Free, no account needed. A historical simulation with modelled costs, not a forecast.

Test a trading rule against holding. Keep the evidence and build your research from there.

support@estockes.comSupport replies within 1-2 business days.

Product

  • Home
  • Pricing
  • Free tools
  • Calculators
    • Compounding
    • Position size
    • Risk and reward
    • Leveraged ETF decay
    • Day trading account checker
  • Academy - free course
  • Test a strategy
  • Strategies we tested
  • Compared with TradingView
  • Compared with Finviz
  • Compared with Investing.com
  • Test a rule without code
  • System status
  • What's new

Company

  • About
  • Contact
  • Support

Legal

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Refunds
  • Security
  • Data request
Review us on Trustpilot (opens in a new tab)

Share your honest experience.

Featured on LaunchBuffeStockes - Featured on LaunchBuckestockes on VibeRank
© 2026 estockes - estockes.com · Operated by Eylon Sabag · Prices in USD

estockes is a research and analytics tool, not a registered investment adviser, broker-dealer, or financial planner. Nothing here is investment, financial, legal, or tax advice. All content is for informational and educational purposes only. Trading involves substantial risk of loss; past performance does not guarantee future results. You trade at your own risk.

Mailing address (correspondence only)
800 N. King St, Suite 304-2048, Wilmington, DE 19801, USAThe operator is Eylon Sabag, an Israeli sole proprietor. This iPostal1 address receives correspondence; it is not a U.S. office or a separate U.S. company.